| 2023 | Minneapolis, MN | A | San Francisco - Fury Unleashed |
| | B | New Orleans - Dream Skittles |
| | C | Columbus - United Elite |
| | D | Fort Lauderdale - Riptide |
| | E | Orlando - Liberty Baggers |
| | Legends* C | Palm Springs - Greyhounds |
| | Legends* D | Atlanta - Daddies |
| 2022 | Dallas, TX | A | Phoenix - Charlie’s AZ Toros |
| | B | Atlanta - Primetime Elite |
| | C | Orlando - Liberty |
| | D | Dallas - Green Sox |
| | E | Birmingham - Sliders |
| | Masters C | Orlando - Swag |
| | Masters D | Washington D.C. - Big Blue |
| 2021 | Columbus, OH | A | Phoenix - Charlie’s AZ Toros |
| | B | Columbus - Grizz |
| | C | New Orleans - Skittles United |
| | D | Columbus - Capitals |
| | E | Columbus - Ban'd |
| | Masters C | Palm Springs - Greyhounds |
| | Masters D | Orlando - Swag Sportswear |
| 2020 | **Year Suspended due to COVID-19 | | |
| 2019 | Kansas City, MO | A | Phoenix - Charlie’s AZ Toros |
| | B | Los Angeles - Rebels |
| | C | Atlanta - Wet Demons |
| | D | Dallas - Devils |
| | E | Atlanta - Chargers |
| | Masters C | Fort Lauderdale - Alive & Kicking |
| | Masters D | Fort Lauderdale - SilverHawks |
| 2018 | Tampa, FL | A | Orlando - Unicorns |
| | B | Knoxville - Cyclones & Orlando - Voltage |
| | C | Mid-Atlantic - Thunder |
| | D | Mid-Atlantic - Norfolk Gunners |
| | Masters C | Houston - Hey Daddy! |
| | Masters D | Palm Springs - Desert Dogs & Philadelphia - Triple Play |
| 2017 | Portland, OR | A | Palm Springs - Rounders 2.0 |
| | B | Austin - Hot Flash |
| | C | Twin Cities - Steel |
| | D | Long Beach - Pegasus D |
| | Masters C | Fort Lauderdale - Code Blue |
| | Masters D | Dallas - Fossil Fuel |
| 2016 | Austin, TX | A | Dallas - Texas Force - Powered by Woody's |
| | B | Los Angeles - Thunder |
| | C | Kansas City - Cocktails |
| | D | Phoenix - Saints |
| | Masters | New York - Cranky Yankees |
| 2015 | Columbus, OH | A | Houston - Force |
| | B | Columbus - Grizzlies |
| | C | Austin - Outlaws |
| | D | Tampa - Pitch Slapped |
| | Masters | San Diego - Marine Layer |
| 2014 | Dallas, TX | A | Palm Springs - Rounders 2.0 |
| | B | Atlanta - Show Stoppers |
| | C | Las Vegas - Grease Monkeys |
| | D | Los Angeles - Swingers |
| | Masters | New York - Cranky Yankees |
| 2013 | Washington, D.C. | A | Houston - Force |
| | B | Boston - Blizzard |
| | C | Orlando - Fury Unleashed |
| | D | Mid-Atlantic - Lightning |
| | Masters | Southern New England - Cranky Yankees |
| 2012 | Minneapolis, MN | A | Atlanta - Sluggers |
| | B | Long Beach - Rounders 2.0 |
| | C | Tampa - Venom |
| | D | Seattle - Inferno |
| | Masters | Seattle - Stroke |
| 2011 | Chicago, IL | A | Atlanta - Venom |
| | B | Boston - Alley Gators |
| | C | Las Vegas - Rat Pack |
| | D | Boston - Good Times |
| | Masters | Chicago - Side Track Classic |
| 2010 | Columbus, OH | A | Los Angeles - Vipers & Orlando - Force |
| | B | Dallas - TKO |
| | C | Austin - Shady Ladies |
| | D | Boston - Ramrod Machine |
| 2009 | Milwaukee, WI | A | Phoenix - Toros |
| | B | Chicago - Spin Cougars |
| | C | Fort Lauderdale - Cyclones |
| | D | Nashville - Players |
| 2008 | Seattle, WA | A | Los Angeles - Vipers |
| | B | Boston - Crew |
| | C | Dallas - Woody's Xplosion |
| | D | Seattle - Atomic |
| 2007 | Phoenix, AZ | A | Atlanta - Venom |
| | B | Orlando - Force |
| | C | Memphis - Heat |
| | D | Atlanta - Wet Demons |
| 2006 | Fort Lauderdale, FL | A | Los Angeles - Vipers |
| | B | Los Angeles - Killer B's |
| | C | Nashville - Tribe |
| | D | Chicago - Jackhammer Heat |
| 2005 | San Diego, CA | A | Los Angeles - Vipers |
| | B | Washington, D.C. Disturbance |
| | C | Seattle - Blue Sox |
| | D | Tampa - Titans |
| 2004 | Dallas, TX | A | Atlanta - Venom |
| | B | Phoenix Calamus/IONSZ Crush |
| | C | Virginia Beach - Evil Empire |
| | D | Memphis - Barflies |
| 2003 | Washington, D.C. | A | Los Angeles - Stray Cats |
| | B | Seattle - Monarchs |
| | C | Chicago - Cougar's |
| | D | Los Angeles - El Dorado Knights |
| 2002 | Portland, OR | A | Los Angeles - Stray Cats |
| | B | Fort Lauderdale - Alibi Demons |
| | C | Norfolk Cavaliers |
| | D | Chicago - Little Dog Properties |
| 2001 | San Francisco, CA* | A | Los Angeles - Stray Cats |
| *25th Anniversary | B | Los Angeles - Destroyers |
| | C | Fort Lauderdale - Chardees Stingrays |
| 2000 | Toronto, Canada | A | Los Angeles - Stray Cats |
| | B | Boston - Jackhammers |
| | C | Fort Lauderdale - Chardees Stingrays |
| 1999 | Kansas City, MO | A | Los Angeles - Stray Cats |
| | B | Kanas City - Dixie Belles Sharps |
| | C | San Francisco - Posse |
| 1998 | Atlanta, GA | A | Los Angeles - Stray Cats |
| | B | Dallas - Sting |
| | C | Boston - Southenders |
| 1997 | San Diego, CA | A | Los Angeles - Stray Cats |
| | B | Twin Cities - Gay 90's Bandits |
| | C | Toronto - The Crew |
| 1996 | Minneapolis, MN | A | Los Angeles - Stray Cats |
| | B | New York - Sunny Day Knights |
| | C | San Francisco - Muderer's Row |
| 1995 | Seattle, WA | A | Los Angeles - Stray Cats |
| | B | San Diego - Rich's ACES |
| | C | Washington, D.C. - JR's Gamecocks |
| 1994 | Nashville, TN | A | Los Angeles - Stray Cats |
| | B | New York - Dugout |
| | C | Dallas - JR's |
| 1993 | Philadelphia, PA | A | Norfolk - Outlaws |
| | B | Seattle - Elite |
| | C | San Francisco - AIDS Foundation Golden Bears |
| 1992 | Los Angeles, CA | A | Boston - Fritz |
| | B | Philadelphia - Woody's |
| | C | Atlanta - Ritz Sluggers |
| 1991 | Boston, MA | Open | Los Angeles - Griffs
|
| | Rec | Los Angeles - Blaze |
| 1990 | Pittsburgh, PA | Open | San Francisco - Uncle Bert's Bombers |
| | Rec | Philadelphia - Blue Parrot |
| 1989 | Atlanta, GA | Open | Los Angeles - Griffs |
| | Rec | San Francisco - Galleon |
| 1988 | Dallas, TX | Open | Twin Cities - Cloud 9 |
| | Rec | New York - Ty's Chelsea Breakers |
| 1987 | Boston, MA | Open | Twin Cities - Cloud 9 |
| 1986 | Boston, MA | Open | Los Angeles - Slammers |
| 1985 | Boston, MA | Open | Houston - Briar Patch |
| 1984 | Boston, MA | Open | Twin Cities - Gay 90's |
| 1983 | Boston, MA | Open | Chicago - Sidetrack |
| 1982 | Boston, MA | Open | San Francisco - Pendulum |
| 1981 | Boston, MA | Open | Los Angeles - Griffs |
| 1980 | Boston, MA | Open | Los Angeles - Griffs |
| 1979 | Boston, MA | Open | Los Angeles - Rusty Nail |
| 1978 | Boston, MA | Open | Los Angeles - Griffs |
| 1977 | Boston, MA | Open | San Francisco - Badland |
